Bethlehem and the 1874 incorporation
Facts checked as of · carmelindiana.wiki editorial team
Carmel began as the Town of Bethlehem.[1][1]The City of Carmel's history page says that on April 13, 1837, John Felps (Phelps), Alexander Mills, Seth Green and Daniel Warren laid out a plat of 14 lots.[1]In 1874, a referendum of 33 in favor and 12 against incorporated the town under the name Carmel.[1]
The 1837 plat
The city's chronicle places the plat in a period when Andrew Jackson was president of the United States and describes the area as previously inhabited by Delaware (Miami) Indians and soon inhabited by Quakers.[1]The first general store was constructed in 1837, and a framed schoolhouse was built near the town's crossroads in 1845.[1]The Carmel Clay History Museum says the original settlement was centered at Main and Range Line Road and grew slowly as a farm town during its first 50 years, with a substantial number of Quaker pioneers who opened a meeting house and school.[2]
The post office and the 1874 name
A post office was established in 1846.[1][2][3]The city's history page says residents were notified that the United States Post Office already had another Indiana town registered as Bethlehem, and that the 1874 incorporation adopted the name Carmel.[1]The history museum notes that a post office had been established with the name Carmel nearly 30 years before the 1874 incorporation.[2]Wikipedia adds that the name Carmel is a reference to 1 Samuel 25:2 and the biblical settlement of Carmel.[3]That biblical explanation is Wikipedia's account, not a statement on the city's history page.
Common questions
When was Bethlehem platted?
April 13, 1837, according to the City of Carmel's history page.[1]
Related pages
References
All sources retrieved November 16, 2026, unless a source is dated in the text.